Heat Recovery from Stack Emissions at Kellogg's Co.


Team EX: C. Ryan Alexander, Kevin Dore, Jeff Ewing, Kalyan Kumar, Brandon Sherrieb, Jeremy Shinko
Sponsor:  John Legarski II
Faculty Advisor: Dr. Savas Yavuzkurt
 
 
    Kellogg's Co. produces their Nutrigrain and Pop Tarts at their Muncy, PA plant.  During the baking process, heat is lost through the oven stacks, costing the plant thousands of dollars annually.  The purpose of this project is to quantify the amount of heat lost in the plant, determine where the greatest heat sink is located, and design a system of recovering heat from the major heat sink. 
 
                                                                               
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

 
                                                                           
 
 

Identification of Heat Sources:  The major heat sources found in the plant were:

Temperature measurements showed the overall temperature of the plant to be roughly 20 degrees C, on a 10C day in February.  Measurements in the stack of the ovens read measurements ranging from 100C to 250C.  It was determined that this source of heat would be highly suitable for a heat exchanger design.  It was calculated that the plant loses 405.5 kW, which is 35035200 KJ/day.

Heat Exchanger Design:

A finned-cross flow heat exchanger was used to recover the lost heat of the exhaust oven stacks.  The design involves combining the exhuast from the three ovens into one pipe.  Attached to this pipe is the heat exchanger.  There will be 19 tubes flowing with 2 rows, across a 2 ft wide pipe, with a total area of 8ft2.  The working fluid for this design will be water, which will have to be piped up to the heat exchanger then circulated back down to where it will be used in the plant. 

Medium Heat Transfer Coefficient
Exhaust from ovens 221 W/m^2 K
Air in tubes 135 W/m^2 K
Water in tubes 20044 W/m^2 K
Overall for air to air 78 W/m^2 K
Overall for water to air 196 W/m^2 K

A second type of heat exchanger design was attempted using the oven stacks.  The only modification from the previous finned-cross flow heat exchanger was the removal of the fins and the use of air as the working fluid.  This drastically reduced the amount of components needed for the system to run, but is limited to only winter use in the plant.  The heat transfer coefficient was reduced by roughly a third to 78 W/m^2 K, with a pressure drop less than 800 PA. There will be 4 rows and 19 columns to this design. 

There are several advantages and disadvantages to both systems.  The air to water system has a much greater heat transfer coefficient, so it will transfer the greatest amount of heat from the stacks.  However, this system will require the greatest amount of additional components. 

The air to air system is the easiest to implement, only requiring a fan to blow the cool air into the exchanger.  The heated air can be ventilated throughout the plant.  The major disadvantage of this system however is the drastically reduced heat transfer coefficient, and the reality that this system will be unusable during the summer months because of the need to cool the plant instead of heating it further.

The scope of this project was limited to the initial measurements and the design of the heat exchanger for the plant.  Additional research is needed in the following areas:

Updated April 22, 2004

Contact the Group